• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9739
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
EVENTS
West England Bylines
Advertisement
  • Home
    • Get involved
  • News
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Business
  • Features
  • Region
VIDEO
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • Get involved
  • News
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Business
  • Features
  • Region
No Result
View All Result
West England Bylines
Home News Brexit

In Truss we trust?

Johnson's resignation fired the starting pistol for a race to the bottom. Liz Truss is the bookies' favourite. The question is: why oh why?

Peter Burke by Peter Burke
25 July 2022
in Brexit, Economy, Education, Environment, Opinion, Politics, Trade
Reading Time: 10 mins read
A A
Liz Truss

Image by UK Government on Flickr. Licensed by CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

Share on Bluesky

We felt euphoria on 7th July when Boris Johnson announced his departure. It was entirely predictable that this would be short lived. We might have hoped that, contrary to form, his party would move in a more enlightened direction. But such hopes were always naïve. The Big Brother-like elimination process saw off any halfway moderate candidates early on. The two who remain leave us scratching our heads and wondering whether a party with 357 MPs could not have done better.

Among the 150,000 or so Tory party members, no doubt there are some who think they are lucky to have a choice between Truss and Sunak. Some 2,000 are pleading to have Johnson back on the ballot paper, or threatening to write his name if it is not there. I’m not sure whether that says more about their naivety or about the truly dreadful choice with which they have been presented. And many members of that constituency will be looking for evidence of who among the candidates is most isolationist, inward looking and nativistic.

So what we can look forward to over the next few weeks is two candidates competing viciously to appeal to that tiny segment (0.25%) of the population by making promises on the economy, immigration, relations with Europe and human rights, promises which I hope the opposition parties are carefully recording and getting ready to play back in the run up to the next general election, when at last the people of the UK, who are as a whole much more enlightened, will be able to make up their own minds whether such policies are really what they want. And if what we have seen so far is anything to go by, we can look forward to more debates in which both candidates knock chunks out of each other and generate damaging footage for Labour to use in the future party political broadcasts.

Let’s just imagine that you are a fairly enlightened Tory party member casting your vote. I have it on good authority that there are such people. You look at the opinion polls (Truss 24% ahead) and the bookies’ odds (Truss 9/4 on) which at the moment are pointing towards a Truss victory. You are not entirely surprised, knowing that you are part of an electorate which is not even typical of Tory voters, never mind the population at large, being well-heeled, predominantly over 60, strongly tempted by tax cuts for the wealthy, and very far from being colour blind. You look at Liz Truss’s CV and realise that she is by far the more experienced politician of the two, having already been a minister when Sunak (and indeed Starmer) was elected for the first time in 2015. Over a number of years, she has worked at Education, DEFRA, the Treasury, the Justice Department, the Department of Trade and the Foreign Office. And she does not have the baggage, as Sunak has, of a police conviction for breaking Covid rules together with Boris Johnson.

And yet…

Never passed up an opportunity to fail

With all the high offices she has held list she has had plenty of opportunity to demonstrate competence. Not a bit of it. It was she, as justice secretary, who allowed the Daily Mail to get away with labelling justices of the Divisional Court, in the Miller case, “enemies of the people”. She may have disagreed with the Court’s ruling, but she had an obligation to act, and I’m not sure whether her failure to do so was a result of fear, incompetence or an intention to undermine public respect for law and order.

As the UK’s trade negotiator she made countless rollover deals which were no better than what the UK had before as an EU member although in some cases so badly worded that they may well prove to be a ticking time bomb. She repeatedly boasts about – rather than being ashamed of – her trade deals with Australia and New Zealand, which we know to be of no value to the economy and to undercut British farmers with cheap, low quality produce; furthermore those trade deals will result in an increase in shipping, with all the environmental damage that ensues. Is it a surprise, then, that her lip service to honouring net zero rings hollow? Especially as she is the candidate who has promised to place a moratorium of unspecified duration on green taxes?

That notorious front page. Truss did nothing

As to her other boast, that she as Foreign Secretary led the UK’s response to the invasion of Ukraine, really what that boils down to is that she may have got out of bed early on the morning of February 24th. On the other hand, what Foreign Secretary Liz Truss has been doing is leading on the Northern Ireland Protocol Bill, which threatens what almost everybody outside this government describes as a serious breach of international law. She has doubled down on the Rwanda policy, even though she must know that it is inhumane, ineffective and unaffordable. She is threatening actively to undermine human rights in the UK. And she has form on disregard for human rights.

Why should she act in this way? The clue is in her support. She is the darling of the ERG and the right-wing press despite having voted remain. Perhaps they see her as having the conviction of a convert. More likely they see her as a soft touch, easily manipulated, and in their debt. Her cabinet will undoubtedly be full of people like Steve Baker and Bill Cash, with even the smattering of moderates from the Johnson era consigned to the backbenches. Will liberals start to feel nostalgia for that era? Perish the thought.

And I am not trying to say that those policies are just hers. At every opportunity her rival is following here down the populist rabbit hole, seeing that as the only way to stay in the race.

The last thing Britain wants or needs is a Boris Johnson Mark 2, but there is nothing Britain can do to stop Tory activists handing the keys of Number 10 to another wild blond opportunist whose primary talent is the spinning of fairytales.

Andrew Rawnsley

Fantasy economics

At the moment Truss is profiting from her promises on taxation. It is sad that this should be the kind of issue on which an election is fought. After all, any prime minister coming into office should have the flexibility to change economic policy according to circumstances, and it is a mistake for either candidate to paint themselves into a corner at this point. Furthermore, on this issue at least Sunak is right, she is basing her tax plans on fantasy economics. Even if she could make her figures add up, she avoids talking about the pain which would be caused to public services by her tax policy. On the Today programme recently she was unable to answer the most basic questions, for example the size of debt interest repayments. She is basing her proposals on the advice of others, notably Patrick Minford, the Brexiteer economist whose predictions have already been proven mistaken on an industrial scale.

A ’journey’

And then there is her Damascene conversion on Brexit. She is stigmatised by some in her party because she was once a remainer. She tells us that she has “been on a journey” but is unable to explain what that means. She is not just telling us that Brexit is a popular option, which of course it has now ceased to be, but it was the right option for the country. This at a time when the harms of Brexit are becoming more and more manifest, just now to anybody setting off on holiday, but also of course over the past 18 months to farmers, fishers, exporters, scientists, performing artists and anybody working in the NHS. And yet this is something which neither candidate is even mentioning. Liz Truss tells us that “some of the portents of doom didn’t happen”. I think she means predictions of doom, but either way she is saying by implication that some of them did indeed come to pass. A fact which is frankly undeniable to anybody with their eyes open. So I am still waiting to hear what wonderful evidence she changed her mind. And the simple mantra “will of the people” is not good enough, nobody ever voted to leave the single market and customs union.

The sketch writer’s darling

Liz Truss’s arrival on the scene, with her comical ineptitude, will be extremely welcome to sketch writers, mimics and satirists. She is daily giving us sound bites showing her profound ignorance and infelicity with words. She does not look as if she is in her comfort zone. And yet, when you roll back to pre referendum days, the old videos of Truss the Remainer show somebody who was almost verging on articulate. Those days are gone. What does that tell us? Does she believe a word she is saying? Does she even understand it?

From the perspective of those of us who wish to see an end to the Tory nightmare, one major plus is that her premiership is unlikely to last more than two years. On current predictions a Truss led Tory party will not win a majority in the next general election, short of a major transformation on her part.

So should our hypothetical enlightened Tory vote for Sunak? He may be bright, articulate and presentable, and he may be the one, unlike Truss, who left Johnson’s cabinet before the very last minute, but like his competitor he has a lot of questions to answer about his empathy, his motives and about the company he keeps. It is a sad reflection on our times and his party that he is somehow regarded as the “left wing candidate” of the two. His biggest recommendation is that he is not Liz Truss. Is that really enough? You tell me.

The author is Chair of Oxford For Europe, and this article is based on a blog on the OfE. The views stated here are those of the author, and not necessarily those of Oxford For Europe.
Some of the points made here were put on Radio 4’s Any Answers

Tags: General Election
Previous Post

New women MPs in French National Assembly

Next Post

The Tory Party: Morally Not Fit to Govern

Peter Burke

Peter Burke

Peter was born in Dublin, of Irish and German heritage. He came to England for a year in 1982, and, having decided he liked working in the NHS, never got round to going back. He has worked in Oxford as a GP for the past 33 years, latterly very part-time. He is a senior clinical lecturer at Oxford University, where he teaches communication skills to medical students, and he is a GP appraiser and examiner. He is chair of the UK Metric Association and chair emeritus of Oxford for Europe. He has three children, living in Oxfordshire, Leipzig and Hollywood, and five grandchildren. https://www.linkedin.com/in/peter-burke-258a9416/

Related Posts

Silhouette of a person drinking from a plastic water bottle under a bright sun in a clear blue sky, with water droplets cascading from the bottle.
Climate Emergency

Climate change is a health emergency that budgets cannot ignore

by Hammad Gillani
6 November 2026
Everyone is an important piece of the jigsaw
Education

Growing up with autism: understanding a different way of experiencing the world

by Bethany Wickson-Dix
5 November 2026
A heard of sheep in a field at night lit up by red fireworks in the sky
Opinion

A bang too far: isn’t it high time we rethought fireworks?

by Kay Johnstone
4 November 2026
Greenish demon-face wall sculpture with yellow horns and a wide open mouth showing teeth; a decorative architectural carving on a gray wall.
Democracy

The midterm monsters: a moment of danger – and opportunity for Europe and democracy

by Claire Jones
28 October 2026
Photo of Donald Trump and Nigel Farage with thumbs up
Democracy

Democracies die slowly then suddenly

by Paul Ryder
27 October 2026
Next Post
VIP Lane - Source: Malcolm Laverty

The Tory Party: Morally Not Fit to Govern

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

BROWSE BY TAGS

Advice Arctic Artificial Intelligence Autism Best for Britain Brexit Bristol climate Climate Change Community Cotswolds Craftivism Democracy Development Domestic Violence Economics Education Environment EU Farage Flood Gaza General Election Global Warming Housing Human Nature Oxford Pedestrian Planning pollution Populism Press release Private Equity Putin Region sewage technology Traffic Transport Trump University of Oxford VAWG video Westbury People's Gallery World War II
West England Bylines

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in West England and beyond.

West England Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Get involved
  • Letters
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2020-2026 West England Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9739

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Europe
    • Health
    • Media
    • Transport
    • World
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Energy
    • Farming
    • Technology
    • Trade
  • Features
    • Broken Britain
    • Climate Emergency
    • Ukraine Conflict
    • Women in Focus
  • Politics
    • Democracy
    • Electoral Reform
    • Equality
    • Human Rights
    • Immigration
  • Society
    • Book Reviews
    • Culture
    • Dance
    • Food
    • Heritage
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Sport
  • Region
    • Bristol and Bath
    • Gloucestershire
    • Herefordshire and Worcestershire
    • Oxfordshire
    • Swindon
    • Wiltshire
    • Society
  • Opinion
  • Cartoons
  • Events
  • Sewage Watch
  • Get involved
  • Authors and editors

Newsletter sign up

CROWDFUNDER

© 2020-2026 West England Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9739