In 2001. Boris Johnson succeeded Michael Heseltine as our local MP in Henley. I do not need to expand on the contrast between the two. Johnson moved on in 2008 to become Mayor of London. I got to know him, and we had discussions and correspondence about the Iraq war, the health service and other issues.
There was no mention in the noughties of leaving the EU. It’s something which at that time would not have occurred to either of us as a possibility, much less a good idea. I wrote to him again in the run up to the referendum. Looking back at this letter, I cannot help thinking how prescient it was.
But that was not just me. Many voices were saying the same.
I did not mention Ireland at the time. It occurred to me, as an Irishman, as a big issue, but only one of many. Even most of my compatriots would not have foreseen the gravity of the problems around the backstop, nor that it would be a deal breaker. I think, even then, that I recognised that any mention of Ireland would go way over Johnson’s head. The sad thing is it still does.
Was there ever a response from Johnson? What do you think?!
24 May 2016
Dear Boris,
You may remember me from when we met in your surgery in Thame and talked about the Iraq invasion in 2003. Again, I have cause to contact you, this time about the referendum.
Suppose Leave wins. Suppose on 24 June Mr Cameron resigns. Some unfortunate will have to step into his shoes and face the following challenges:
- How to stem the flow of capital out of the UK which all authoritative sources predict.
- How to mitigate the damage caused to the City of London and to manufacturing industry. (Need I remind you, who said only a few months ago: “leaving would cause at least some business uncertainty, while embroiling the Government for several years in a fiddly process of negotiating new arrangements, so diverting energy from the real problems of this country – low skills, low social mobility, low investment, etc. – that have nothing to do with Europe”?).
- How to explain to the electorate that they have been fed false expectations about British negotiating power outside the EU, particularly when the [then] current relative strength of the British economy turns out to be no more than a temporary blip.
- How to negotiate new trade deals with the residual European Union, most of whose leaders would by then have learnt to treat this country with hostility and suspicion.
- How to negotiate trade deals with third countries such as the USA, who have already made it clear that they would not treat us as a priority.
- How to explain that the cost of favourable trade deals with the EU would be continuing contributions to the EU budget, continuing compliance with EU standards, and free movement of labour, as happens in Norway and other EFTA countries; and how to explain why we had suddenly sacrificed the right to influence those standards and regulations.
- In a full-blown Brexit scenario, how to cope with a major outflow of skilled labour from the UK economy.
- How to explain to the well over 2 million British expatriates in the EU countries why they have suddenly lost their right to live and work in their adopted home; potentially dealing with repatriation of many of these people, a large proportion of whom are not economically productive.
- How to explain that, contrary to predictions, leaving the EU does not absolve us from the obligation to accept migrants from other parts of the world. It will make it much more difficult to negotiate with the French on security at Calais and will also make it more difficult to achieve a united European stand on immigration, which at a time like this is more important than ever.
- Presiding over the break-up of the United Kingdom, which would be almost inevitable given that [then First Minister of Scotland] Nicola Sturgeon has already made clear that for her there would be grounds for a second referendum. As we know, in the first referendum many Scottish voters favoured the status quo mainly because it meant staying within Europe *.
- How to police a land border with Scotland (still in the EU), including the full panoply of customs and immigration checks.
These are just a few of the challenges such a person will face. Do you really want to be that person? Do you really want to side with Donald Trump, George Galloway, Nigel Farage, Vladimir Putin, Marine Le Pen, and their flat earth colleagues in the face of persuasive arguments and hard evidence from the Treasury, the IMF, all the main UK parties, and most of our overseas allies? You heard Mr Obama’s views, and he is an Anglophile compared to some of his possible successors.
You have written about the days of empire and know they are gone. Whatever the Little Englanders say, turning the clock back to when ‘Britain stood alone and was great’ is not an option.
You are an educated man and know well enough the difference between refutation and denial. Don’t you feel uncomfortable when Leave campaigners deny all the evidence without refuting it? Phrases like ‘project fear’ may sound good, but you and I know they have no meaning.
Years after our conversation over Iraq you changed your mind and saw the light. You left it too late. Please don’t repeat that mistake.
Best wishes,
Peter
*That bit I happily admit I got wrong
Editor’s notes in square brackets







