Over the next five to ten years it is estimated that flood premiums will go up somewhere between 500% and 700%.
Insurers factor in the risk to clients’ property, and to their bottom line, raising premiums or ceasing completely to insure when the risks seem extreme, but they are completely blinkered to their part in the cause of the existential risk that threatens us all.
Insurabilty
It is not as though they aren’t aware of the portents. In 2015, the CEO of AXA, a major insurance company, said that a world warmed by the four degrees, that the Committee on Climate Change warns we are on track to hit, “certainly would not be [insurable]”.
In their 2020 report, Risky business: the climate and the macroeconomy, JP Morgan warned:
“BAU* opens the earth to a greater likelihood of a catastrophic outcome […]. It also increases the likelihood that the costs of dealing with climate change will go up as action is delayed. And finally, it increases the likelihood that the changes in the climate will be irreversible.”
AXA is in the frame for continuing to underwrite oil companies ‘in transition’, and JP Morgan beats all by far for its funding of fossil fuel ventures to the tune of $434 billion.
The cognitive dissonance is deafening.
But the glaring blind spot (no doubt due to the £13.7bn each year in premiums from customers across the industry) is that by underwriting the perpetrators of increased risk, they are signing the industry’s own death warrant as well as ours. As Lenin famously said:
“When it comes time to hang the capitalists, they will vie with each other for the rope contract.”
Joanna Warrington, campaigner with Fossil Free London said:
“London’s banks and finance sector have been ignoring all the warning signs while pouring billions into fossil fuel expansion. Their profit is our loss. Financing new fossil fuel developments is incompatible with a safe future.”
Protesting against insurers
We know that consciences can be pricked and ‘jumpers’ can be talked down. In October, Extinction Rebellion (XR), in conjunction with Fossil Free London, occupied the offices of ten of Lloyd’s insurers demanding they reject climate-wrecking projects particularly the proposed West Cumbria coal mine and the East Africa Crude Oil Pipeline (EACOP).
As a result of people power and the disinfectant of sunlight, 28 major insurance companies have now ruled out underwriting EACOP, and six insurers have so far ruled out underwriting the West Cumbria mine (AEGIS Managing Agency, Argenta Syndicate Management, Hannover Re, Talanx and Atrium Underwriters Ltd). This win represents a new phase in the campaign to stop both projects from going ahead.
The Cumbrian mine, which, should it go ahead, is expected to emit 220 million tonnes of greenhouse gases from the coal extracted over the mine’s lifetime, was laughably deemed by Michael Gove to be “climate neutral or slightly beneficial”. Factoring the actual burning of the coal seems to have passed him by but not the 100k people who joined the campaign against it.
Ex chief scientific advisor Sir David King called the decision to go ahead with the mine, “an incomprehensible act of self-harm”. And Green MP Caroline Lucas called it, “a climate crime against humanity”. She said:
“Instead of backing 1000s of green jobs and sustainable, long-term economic revival, the Government has backed a climate-busting, backward-looking, stranded asset coal mine.”
Stranded assets should be kryptonite to insurers. All reason has deserted them.
#StopEACOP is a global coalition campaigning against the proposed pipeline and associated oil fields at Tilenga and Kingfisher in East Africa.
This alliance aims to halt the project that plans to transport approximately 216,000 barrels of crude oil per day, equivalent to 10.9 million metric tons annually, through a 1,443-kilometre pipeline from Hoima, Uganda, to the port of Tanga in Tanzania. The movement is gaining traction, exerting pressure on the remaining backers and financiers of the undertaking.
A ground-breaking resolution acknowledging the dire consequences of EACOP for both human rights and the climate has been officially endorsed by the European Parliament. Seeing the way the wind is blowing, AEGIS London, Arch Capital Group Ltd and Britam Holdings recently announced they would not offer the project insurance coverage.
UK’s new oil and gas fields
Of the 46 international insurers in the running to underwrite the Jackdaw gas field, or the Cambo and Rosebank oil fields, the only firms who said they would not cover the projects on climate grounds were Aviva and the Italian firm, Generali. Aviva’s underwriting strategy explicitly specifies that the company has ceased offering insurance for “any new fossil fuel or mining extraction projects”.
Inevitably, the oil and gas industry have said that it would be “wildly misguided” to stop insuring new fields, arguing that gas would continue to be needed as a backup to renewable sources of energy.
However, this flies in the face of the findings of the Fossil Fuel Exit Strategy: An orderly wind down of coal, oil and gas to meet the Paris Agreement in which Tzeporah Berman, Chair of the Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative writes:
“This new report shows clearly that we have more than enough fossil fuels above ground and under production and that we have the technology and renewable energy capacity to more than meet the world’s energy needs. Fast tracking a wind down of oil, gas and coal and focusing on expanding renewable production and infrastructure is not only possible, but it will save lives.”
Conclusion
Insurance companies play an integral part in the financial framework which allows for new oil and gas projects. Without insurance new oil and gas exploration cannot go ahead.
Tessa Khan, director of the campaign group Uplift, has said that insurers were, “at last catching on” that short term profits for the fossil fuel companies would soon be dwarfed by the coming cataclysm they presage.
Indeed, the case for divestment has intensified since the International Energy Agency (IEA) report Net Zero by 2050, a roadmap for the global energy sector, summed up by the IEA’s executive director, Fatih Birol:
“If governments are serious about the climate crisis, there can be no new investments in oil, gas and coal, from now – from this year.”
In recent years, thirty-eight global insurers have either refused or restricted underwriting for new coal mines.
However, nine major global insurers and Lloyd’s of London, have quit the Net-Zero Insurance Alliance (NZIA) a group instigated by former Bank of England governor Mark Carney before COP 26 in Glasgow, as growing political pressure and legal fears once again plunge climate initiatives into crisis. These include AXA, Allianz and Scor, as well as Japan’s Sompo Holdings.
One step forward and two steps back. We need to keep the pressure up.
As the Guardian revealed, the total potential emissions of all “carbon bomb” oil and gas projects in development is 17.5 times the entire global emissions from 2023, which is enough to take us to an un-survivable seven degrees and beyond this century. The insurance industry needs to look to its own insurability and audit itself accordingly.
* BAU = business as usual.
We want to hear your views. Please send any comments to editor@westenglandbylines.co.uk

CLICK HERE TO DONATE TO OUR CROWDFUNDER
HELP US BECOME STRONGER SO THAT WE CAN CONTINUE TO DELIVER POWERFUL CITIZEN JOURNALISM!







