Here we have two bar charts taken from eve-of-poll election leaflets delivered to households across the Witney constituency in June 2024. (Sadly, we offer no prizes for guessing which party issued which chart.) You’ll have seen similar statistics shining optimistically up at you from your own doormat. Often, they’re spin, of course, we all know that, but at their worst they’re what ought to be unacceptable distortion; deliberate disinformation.

The Romans used to say “caveat emptor!” which translates as “buyer beware!” Even in Latin, this is wisdom indeed. In today’s world, us ‘emptors’ had better ‘cave’ if we don’t want to be fooled, fuddled, diddled and done.
There’s a joke where I live about election leaflet bar charts like these – the blocks are drawn just the same, we chortle to each other, they’re just filled in different colours. And many a true word is spoken in jest.
In this case, one chart is approximately true and doesn’t mislead (at least on this occasion), but the other, while accurate, is very importantly misleading, nonetheless.
The subtle psychology of deception
On the second of our charts, Britain Predicts did indeed publish statistics towards the end of June, suggesting that the Lib Dem candidate was just a whisker short of our Conservative incumbent. Waiting for this late June prediction, and telling the truth about it, suited that candidate at that moment. But the other chart misleads because although it reports results published by Electoral Calculus, they are from polling taken many weeks before the election. At that moment, in May, the polling was as they report, but the same company offered very different projections in June. By the end of that month, their polling even suggested that the Lib Dem candidate might win the seat and, in the event, he did exactly that.
Printing the out-of-date May projection (in the first chart) such as to intimate that it was the current state of affairs and a likely predictor of outcome is disinformation, frank and rank. I think we may assume that the people who published this nonetheless checked the Electoral Calculus website repeatedly, throughout June. This would make their publication of the very different, elderly, May data an act of disinformation. An attempt to hide information, bend facts, dupe electors and manipulate votes.
What are we to make of this sort of thing? What are we to do about it? Is there anything which can be done about it, or should we just shrug and move on?
Democracy collapses without truth
We need politics. We organise and protect ourselves by means of it, and if we allow it to turn into mush, we can expect nothing but disorder. Only the rich and powerful succeed when politics fails and we know enough about them to recognise that as a horrible idea. Democratic politics is our defence against arbitrary power. We need it to be there, and we need it to work. Democracy, though, is not a given – it’s a process and a battle which must constantly be fought by people with public spirit and good hearts.
For democracy to work, it must be founded on truth. We expect politics to pursue the general wellbeing in a humane democracy, but to succeed in practice it demands a generally accepted reality to which it needs to stay close. Disinformation is untruth, and a particular (and particularly dangerous) species of unreality. The habitual use of disinformation as our political currency steadily debases it. Without trust in what politicians say, politics becomes pointless and unusable; remote, elite, and hostile. It becomes a confusing morass, where calculated disinformation meets a welter of conspiracy theories; where anything can be, and everything is, believed and facts make no difference; where foundations melt and decay and democratic advance falters and dies.
Integrity and accountability begin at the grassroots
So we need to wrench honesty back into politics and it does seem to be up to us to do this. But how?
One way to do it is to get active and support an organisation which monitors and cajoles our Members of Parliament, especially on climate issues, and doggedly insists on honesty in politics. On truth. This excellent organisation is MP Watch (www.mpwatch.org) and they may already have a branch live in your constituency, watching your MP.
If not, you could start one! Three of us did this, in Witney, in July of 2022, and today, just two years later, our constituency has been seized from climate-denialist Conservative hands for the first time in 102 years.
Why not give it a go? You’ll make a difference!
We want to hear your views. Please send any comments to editor@westenglandbylines.co.uk







