Since Trump lobbed one of his defective disinformation grenades into the previously settled argument around this deal, I thought it might be worth a little factual background to counteract the nonsense.
The Chagos Archipelago is a group of seven atolls in the Indian Ocean. Discovered in the first instance by Portuguese explorers in the 16th century, it remained uninhabited until France settled it in 1715 after their colonisation of Mauritius.
The very first recorded claim to the islands was by King Hassan IX of the Maldives in 1561.
After some toing and froing between France and Great Britain, and a defeat of Napoleon, the entire region became part of the British Empire, including Mauritius and the Maldives.
As with most of colonial Britain, we treated the islanders and native people terribly, enslaving them and forcing them to work on plantations and coconut groves.
Fast-forward to the 1960s
At this point, we had struck a deal with the US to lease Diego Garcia to them for a proposed military base. The deal would run for 50 years, with carve outs for automatic extensions in perpetuity.
In order to achieve this, the UK forcibly removed the entire Chagossian population: around 1,500 –2,000 people were deported to Mauritius and the Seychelles. This is widely considered to be an act of ethnic cleansing and one for which the UK should hang its head in shame.
Before this horrific act took place, the UK had agreed a deal to give Mauritius its independence and offered £3mn in compensation. A ‘take it or leave it’ offer that brought further shame to the British side.
The base in Diego Garcia was completed in the 1970s and has been pivotal for operations in Iraq and Afghanistan, among others.
Sovereignty disputes
There have been ongoing legal disputes since the early 2000s with Chagossians claiming their legal rights to the land from which they were expelled. In 2016, the British government asserted that this would never happen.
In 2019, a UN resolution was unanimously passed to force Britain to return the islands to Mauritius … within six months.
We did not.
Even after a UN tribunal hearing in 2021, the UK still refused to grant sovereignty to the Chagossians and to return the islands to their original ownership.
It wasn’t until 2022 that then Foreign Secretary, James Cleverly, announced that he was starting negotiations with Mauritius and intended to allow the resettlement of the Chagossians.
When Cleverly left government a year later, his successor, David Cameron, backtracked and cancelled the resettlement of the islanders.
Chagos, Labour and Trump
After Labour came into power, in July 2024, they finalised the deal started under the Conservatives but held off on ratification until the new president, Donald Trump, had taken office and had a chance to look across the proposal.
On 27th February 2025, Trump agreed to support the deal which ensured long term [read permanent] military presence in Diego Garcia, and signed off on the deal officially in April.
Whilst the deal is still subject to challenges by the islanders and some in Mauritius, there has been widespread misreporting of the details.
One of the well-known tropes is that we are giving our territory to a foreign nation and paying them for the privilege. If you’ve read the paragraphs above, then you will perhaps begin to understand why the UK has to cede control of this island group.
We no longer hold an empire or are colonialists — it is the correct thing to do.
Costs and benefits
The costs involved are wildly misreported up to the eye-watering sum of £35bn, but this is wrong. The most recent figures are that we will lease the land for $101mn per year for 99 years.
The right-wing media will have you believe that we are paying for nothing but, in reality, this is a modest outlay for a hugely strategic military presence and … the US pays for the base on Diego Garcia.
The US avoids any legal or colonial ramifications but pays for the base. The UK pays for legitimacy. The US pays for capability.
Secondary claims about the Chinese involvement are limited and don’t really hold much water. China does have trade agreements with Mauritius but absolutely nothing militarily. The same as the UK does.
That’s my mini explainer on where we stand, I hope it is helpful. But there is one more thing I have to point out … à la Columbo.
More Trump mischief
About 98% of this deal and all the legal wranglings took place under the Conservative government. Ask yourself why we are all just hearing about it now. Why was this not across our media ecosphere when James Cleverly and David Cameron made the actual deal?
Why, since Labour took power and finalised the deal the Tories made, are the media up in arms about it? I think we all know that answers to that little quandary.
Trump’s latest interjection means nothing. He won’t renege on the deal he signed. All he wants to do is sow chaos and uncertainty.
As I wrote yesterday, it’s just noise and distraction from the President, nothing more, but our small-minded press lap it up and spread their lies to belittle the prime minister.
Comments? We want to hear them. Please write to editor@westenglandbylines.co.uk

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.






