The UK Government is failing to adapt to unavoidable coastal changes as part of the climate emergency. But there are other reasons for coastal erosion. The UK is not creating deep reductions in global greenhouse emissions as part of a global effort, pushing the us towards worsening impacts of more powerful storms hitting our coastlines.
Would we want adaptation to climate change policy to include what the government is doing to people on the east coast of England? Edward Devenish’s The Ghost Coast: Britain’s Disappearing Shorelines, Coastal Erosion and Climate Change investigates how people are being treated by remarkably callous governments.
The fall of the east coast of England
Vulnerable coastlines have been collapsing on the east coast of England for centuries. Ports and towns have been lost. Isostatic rebound from the last ice age has ‘rewarded’ the western side of England with modest rises in its land and coasts, tilting the country at the expense of the eastern side.
The heavy pressure of the last ice age pushing land downwards is consequently being gradually relieved. Sediment accumulations make for a vulnerable east coast, at risk from both sea level rise and storm surges tearing into soft cliffs. Communities are gradually being undermined.
Free to move?
Residents of the ‘Ghost Coast’ are not generally free to move home in the face of obvious threats to their homes. In most cases, they have homes that are uninsurable, unsaleable, and doomed to eventual collapse into the sea. To move is to lose everything, and the Government expects victims of its and previous governments’ failed climate policies to pay for the demolition of their own homes before they move out.
Since housing in England is a privilege and not a right, rehousing into temporary accommodation could mean abandoning all of one’s property. In a rich country like the UK, successive governments think this abuse of human rights is acceptable. A very recent estimate suggests coastal erosion in England may have taken at least 183 homes in the past 16 years.
The cliffs closing in on homes
Devenish makes cases of this kind real by meeting with the victims along the ‘Ghost Coast’, whose shrinking gardens and approaching cliff edges tell a tale of inescapable loss to come. The Holderness coast is averaging a loss of two metres of coastline a year. In just this one 40-mile section of coastline, records as far back as the medieval period suggest the complete loss of twenty-nine villages to date. Devenish notes that the disappearance of these communities may be noted in records, but not where their people went.
Hard protection, soft coasts
You cannot put hard protection on a soft coast. The sea will batter, move, or even destroy sea defences that lack strong foundations. You might try nature-based protection of the coastline, but a strong storm could rip out such efforts. And in locations with extensive areas of land at sea level but low populations as in the Wash, even good agricultural land is unlikely to prompt government action for protection.
The Environment Agency’s expression for abandonment is “no active intervention”. In avoiding costs of protection, abandonment may well have its own costs. These include: impacts of a shrinking coastline, the need for estuary protection, loss of agricultural land, and the human tragedy of loss of homes that cannot be measured in money, except perhaps by the Treasury.
Abandoning people
In short, there is no compensation for being at the frontline of coastal erosion. It is not just land being abandoned, it is people. On the east coast they are a long way from Whitehall, and their modest needs are disregarded.
In the ill-named Happisburgh, the North Sea comes to ‘visit’ periodically in storms and the general threat to the community has attracted appreciable media attention. Homes built about 30 years ago are now under threat. But publicity is not help in itself. It should not be confused with any idea of a sudden awakening at Westminster, or a mad rush to provide more funds and powers to the Environment Agency to support people in a time of horrific transition.
Disaster tourism
At Hemsby, buildings created for tourism became, out of necessity, permanent homes. But permanent protection and consideration did not accompany this change of use. Even caravans have become permanent homes here. Annual storms move sand, which constitutes a very modest line of defence against the incursion of the sea. And yes, there really are ‘disaster tourists’ who come to take photos and tut.
What does get protected?
Economics in Whitehall places far higher value on infrastructure than people. So, as Devenish outlines, roads, railways, gas terminals, and ports are all examples of where protection is likely to be provided, if it has not happened already. Precisely how protecting coastal (or estuary) locations with infrastructure deemed valuable will be of use in protecting entire sections of coastline when most of it is unprotected, remains to be revealed.
Future sea level rise and storm realities may defeat ‘protection’. As Devenish mentions, this is all about delay. Infrastructure for coastal protection gives the appearance of something being done while the key strategic question is how best to address entire coastal and estuary needs. Rapid and deep cuts in greenhouse gas emissions are highly likely to be better than delay in making such cuts. Clearly, this is a global need and not one which can be addressed by the UK alone.
Acceleration at the edges of the UK
The Norfolk coast is now losing two to three metres of coastline each year. More frequent and powerful storms every 10 to 20 years now compares with such storms every 50 or 100 years in the past.
Since 2010, locations such as Happisburgh are seeing much more frequent damage to cliffs termed as “a constant state of active failure” by an expert. Being between areas with coastal defences, namely Cromer and Great Yarmouth, is hardly comforting to the residential population on the coast wedged between them.
Long-term vision is needed
A comprehensive set of policies for adaptation to what are at present unavoidable climate change-driven adjustments to the coastline of the UK would be welcome. It certainly does not exist at present, as Devenish has outlined.
The Climate Change Committee has called for both a “more concerted effort” and “significantly more funding” for adaptation. Planning for housing expansion, even in areas at long-term risk of sea level rise and storm damage, cannot be seen as rational. But other forms of infrastructure may require long-term protection which needs looking at critically.
Given the very long periods of planning and development for even quite modest forms of new infrastructure in the UK, governments need to be less frightened of the media and the electorate reacting to fears for the future, and more cognisant of the importance of addressing the long term.
People do not live from one general election to another. They live into their 70s and 80s and many take out mortgages for 25 years, sometimes more. It is a great pity that the long term, as experienced by these people, is not replicated by having governments which plan realistically for the long term. Devenish has provided us all with a sound reminder of the importance of just transitions for people who are literally in the path of major changes.
Comments? We want to hear them. Please write to editor@westenglandbylines.co.uk

Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.






